Comparative Analysis of Spiral Classifier design and ...

This article provides an in-depth comparison between the Spiral Classifier and the Hydrocyclone, two essential pieces of equipment in mineral processing. Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of these classifiers can help you make informed decisions for your milling operations.

Spiral classifiers and hydrocyclones are both used as mineral processing classifiers. Generally, there are four kinds of classifiers in mineral processing: the increased flow hydrocyclone classifier, cone classifier, centrifugal classifier (hydrocyclone), and mechanical classifiers (rake classifier, spiral classifier, and floating tank classifier). In this discussion, we will focus on these two classifiers, as they are the most commonly employed in our milling plants today.

If you want to learn more, please visit our website.

The Spiral Classifier functions as a mechanical classifier. It consists of a U-shaped water tank, spiral device, transmission mechanisms, lifting mechanism, bearings, and several other parts.

Its operational principle involves feeding the milled material into the U-shaped slot through the classifier's feed mouth. The spiral device continually rotates and stirs the material, suspending light, fine particles to flow over the overflow weir, while heavier particles settle at the bottom and are transported back to the discharge port for further grinding.

Spiral Classifier Types

Spiral classifiers can be categorized based on two methods. The first is by the number of screw shafts, classifying them into single and double spiral classifiers. The second is according to the height of the overflow weir, dividing them into high, low weir, and submerged types.

Hydrocyclone Introduction

The hydrocyclone is a centrifugal separation device primarily composed of a feed tube, cone, cylindrical shell, sand mouth, and overflow pipe.

The operational principle of a hydrocyclone involves feeding pulp into its cylinder through the tangent direction of the feeding tube under a pressure of 0.5-2.5 kg/cm². The internal rotation generates a substantial centrifugal force, which separates coarser particles by directing them toward the wall, from where they are discharged through the discharge mouth.

Hydrocyclone Advantages and Disadvantages

Hydrocyclones offer several advantages: they have a simple construction with no moving parts, a compact size that requires less space, high processing capacity per unit area, and convenience in operation and maintenance. Also, classification efficiency and sorting accuracy are remarkably high when in conjunction with a large ball mill. However, they have several disadvantages: they require a pump to deliver pulp, stable working pressure, and have high demands for particle size and concentration of the pulp. They are also susceptible to wear and tear over time.

In contrast, the spiral classifier boasts notable advantages over the hydrocyclone. It is dependable and simple to operate. Its design allows for a finer particle size to overflow smoothly, with a trough slope that facilitates easy sand return to the ball mill. Despite improvements made by domestic mining equipment manufacturers, such as an automatic sand-returning lift device in the spiral classifier by Yantai Xinhai Machinery, some deficiencies remain. The spiral classifier is relatively bulky, has lower classification efficiency, its spindle can fracture, maintenance can be cumbersome, and achieving a finer classification overflow granularity is challenging—especially when the desired granularity is below 0.074mm and comprises over 90% of the feed.

Conclusion

Overall, both the Spiral Classifier and Hydrocyclone are widely utilized throughout various industries, including mining. Each classifier has its own distinct advantages and disadvantages, making them suitable for different applications based on specific operational needs.

To explore the various offerings of Zoneding machine and further enhance your understanding of these classifiers, consider accessing additional resources available on our website.