What is Claw Crane Machine and Why Do We Use Them?

Claw machines, also known as crane games, are popular among youth. These games require players to insert money or tokens to use an arm-like device to grab a stuffed animal, toy, or another prize. They are found in many places, such as cinemas, malls, and arcades.  

Link to Unique Anime

There are many types of claw machines. Play-to-win ones provide an unlimited number of attempts until you win. Single-play machines give you only one chance to grab the prize. These games can be programmed to grab at full strength occasionally. The owners of claw machines can tweak them to ensure a prize is won sometimes.  The chances of winning depend on several factors, including the value of the prizes, the player's skill level, the settings for payout percentage, the speed of the motion, and the grip pick-up and hold strength. 

The element of chance in single-play claw machines and the flexibility in the payout percentage set by the owners raise the question of whether claw machines are a form of gambling.

Single-play claw machines: Games of chance

In , an Ontario Court examined a case concerning the legality of claw machines in single-play mode, where the player has only one chance per credit to win a prize. The court found that although the ability of the player to control the crane’s movement gave the appearance of an element of skill, the game was played as a game of chance, and, therefore, should be prohibited outside of trade fairs and exhibitions.

The trial judge defined the game as “one of mixed skill and chance with an overwhelming degree of chance and merely a dash of skill.”

Online crane games: A twist on the traditional

Typically, claw machine games are played in a physical arcade, but new ways of playing have emerged, including apps where claw machines can be operated remotely through video streaming. “The claw machine is physically located in another country,” says Aria Khosravi, a  Youth Outreach Worker with YMCA Youth Gambling Awareness Program (YGAP). “If you win, the prize is sent to you by mail.”

While physical claw machines are often programmed to make owners a certain amount of money before they pay out a prize, apps can operate differently. For example, you may never win or win on your first try because the app is designed to entice players to keep playing, or you could win multiple times in a row with a catch attached. “To claim your prize, the app may require you to join as a member and pay a monthly fee — and you cannot claim your prize without being a member,” says Khosravi. “And what happens is that after a few months, they may increase the price of membership dramatically.”

 This allows individuals to play potentially riskier games outside of Canada. There could be a scam or no standards for fair play, or your personal and bank information may get compromised.  

Are claw machines a form of gambling?

According to the Criminal Code that governs gambling in Canada, three elements are required for an activity to be considered gambling: Payment to play the game, the resort to chance or a combination of skill and chance to determine the outcome, and an opportunity to win a prize with monetary value.

The gambling elements of claw machines include risking money for a chance at winning a prize and uncertainty about winning a prize in single-play games.

YGAP defines gambling as risking something of value when you don’t know if you will win or lose. Based on this definition, we consider single-play claw machines a gambling activity.

“There’s a business that owns the claw machines, and the primary goal of that business is to make money. People do win, but ultimately, the odds aren’t in your favour. The house, or arcade, has the edge,” says Sarah Hannaford, YGAP’s Youth Outreach Specialist. “The business doesn’t want to pay out more than it’s taking in.”

Single-play claw machines share other characteristics with gambling, including:

• Near misses: It may look like you are grabbing the item, but it can fall at the last minute.
• The illusion of control: You think you have the skill to control the claw, but in reality, it can be set by arcade owners to give out prizes occasionally.
• Audio and visual cues: They are similar to slot machines. 

In some jurisdictions, claw machines are regulated with rules about the types and values of prizes that can be offered, where claw machines can be placed, making the rules that govern the game available to the player, and age restrictions on playing. From paying $1 for one chance at winning a key chain or a stuffed animal to $5 claw machines providing a chance at winning high-end shoes, these machines are popping up everywhere. We see claw machines that charge a relatively high price to play the game and provide high-value prizes. Since single-play claw machines may be gambling, and since it’s unclear how much skill is involved, and still the question remains as to why are claw machines so accessible to youth in Ontario?

Claw machine usage & gambling problems

Claw machines have a wide audience. Even parents are interested in playing because of nostalgia. “It’s a new kind of exciting experience,” says Hannaford. 

While claw machines can be fun, they are not necessarily risk-free. Studies show adults experiencing problems with gambling are more likely to recall using claw machines as youths. Frequent usage of these games as children may be associated with greater gambling problems as adults (Newall et al., , ; Parrado-Gonzalez & Newall, ).

It’s important to have conversations with youth about the risk involved in claw machines and other chance-based games. You pay for an unknown prize with claw machines that do not guarantee a win. You are more likely to lose these games due to the house advantage, so decide if you want to spend money on them. Keep in mind that they are games of chance that can have the potential to cause problems. 

Recognize warning signs

Here are some common warning signs to look out for when playing claw machines or other games of chance:

• Unable to stop playing or thinking about playing
• Spending more than you can afford
• Expecting to win or becoming irritable when not winning
• Playing for extended periods or spending more money
• The game is not fun anymore

It is a good idea to set a budget for entertainment if you choose to play these games and don’t spend more than you can afford. Engage with them as entertainment rather than getting stuck in a cycle of trying to win a particular prize. Make sure you balance playing games with other activities and get enough activity, sleep, and nutrition. 

Additional resources and support

YGAP frequently discusses current gaming trends with youth to help make the connections between gambling and games and to support informed decision-making. Contact us to learn more or to book a free gambling awareness workshop.  

A claw machine is a type of arcade game. Modern claw machines are upright cabinets with glass boxes that are lit from the inside and have a joystick-controlled claw at the top, which is coin-operated and positioned over a pile of prizes, dropped into the pile, and picked up to unload the prize or lack thereof into a chute.[1][2] They typically contain stuffed toys or other cheap prizes, and sometimes contain more expensive items like electronic devices and fashion accessories.[3][4] Claw machines are also known as skill cranes, claw cranes, crane games, teddy pickers, and are known as UFO catchers in Japan due to the claws' resemblance to UFOs.[5][6][7]

If you are looking for more details, kindly visit Claw Crane Machine.

The earliest claw machines are believed to have been created in the late 19th century and inspired by the machines used to build the Panama Canal, while the first patented claw machine, the Erie Digger, was inspired by the creation of the Erie Canal and invented in . It and its successor, the Miami Digger, were popular throughout the United States during the s, specifically during the Great Depression, as carnival attractions and as furniture in public places. By the s, claw machines were ubiquitous in both the United States and Japan; the success of Sega's UFO Catcher machines in the s and s inspired a claw machine craze in the latter country. Claw machines have made appearances in numerous video games, music videos, films, and television shows since at least the s.

In the late s, claw machines became immensely popular in South Korea and Taiwan as cheap entertainment due to their slowing economies at the time, with the number of claw machine arcades in both places rising into the thousands. Also in the s, claw machines that could be remotely controlled via mobile applications or websites began turning up online.

Claw machines are often rigged to modify the claw's strength on each turn, and are consequently considered gambling devices in some jurisdictions.

Early history

Claw machines are believed to have originated in the United States in the s, when they were made to resemble the machines that built the Panama Canal.[7] The first patented claw machine, the Erie Digger, was a glass box containing candy and other small objects, a chute, and a coin-operated miniature steam shovel that moved in an arc, could be moved with a handle, and could be lifted and dropped into the chute using a hand crank.[8] It was invented in , manufactured by the Erie Manufacturing Company, and named after the construction of the Erie Canal. It found success at carnivals, partially because it did not require electricity like other carnival attractions. Throughout the s, it saw use as furniture in train stations, hotels, drugstores, cigar stores, and bus stations, where it was used to keep customers entertained.[2] During the Great Depression, designing intricate, Art Deco claw machines for hotels and stores became a lucrative endeavor.[9]

The Miami Digger, invented by American carnival operator William Bartlett of Miami and patented by him in , improved upon the design of the Erie Digger by using an electric motor and allowing the crane to move around the entire box.[9] It was also known as the Nickel Digger, as it contained money, such as nickels and silver dollars, as prizes; premium versions of the diggers had watches and cigarette lighters as prizes for adults. Bartlett became rich from the popularity of the machines and died in .[2]

Global popularity

In Asia

Japanese companies Sega and Taito began designing trolley-style claw machines in the s.[2] They gained popularity in Japan during the late s, with crane games ranking among Japan's top ten highest-grossing electro-mechanical (EM) arcade games of and .[10][11] Sega released their UFO Catcher claw machine in and made their first shipment of it in .[12] It had sold 10,000 cabinets by , its popularity inspiring Sega's creation of the Dream Catcher in and the New UFO Catcher in while making the UFO Catcher series responsible for 90 percent of stuffed toy claw machine sales.[13] By , its claw could be changed to fit the sizes and shapes of different prizes, and it had become a craze across Japan: arcades started dedicating entire floors to UFO Catcher cabinets—of which Sega had sold over 40,000, making it Sega's best-selling game at the time—and the term "UFO catcher" became synonymous with crane games in Japan.[14][15][16]

Sega Shinjuku Kabukicho, a two-story Sega arcade in Shinjuku, Tokyo containing 477 claw machines, received the Guinness World Record for having the most claw machines in a single venue in , a record previously held by the Taito Station in Fuchū, Tokyo for having 454 machines.[17] As of , Yuka Nakajima of Japan holds the Guinness World Record for being the most successful claw machine player due to winning more than 3,500 Rilakkuma teddy bears from claw machines.[18][19] In , claw machines accounted for more than half of the revenue at Japanese arcades, according to the Japan Amusement Industry Association.[20] Japanese claw machines can also contain cakes as prizes.[21][22]

The number of claw machine arcades and the popularity of claw machines both experienced a sharp increase in South Korea in and , specifically in Seoul neighborhoods with universities like Hongdae and Sinchon. From to , the number of South Korean claw arcades increased from 20 to 1,900, while mentions of claw machines on Korean social networks also increased during that time. Korea JoongAng Daily and The Korea Herald attributed the increased interest to South Korea's harsh economy at the time leading to a desire for cheap entertainment, while U.S. News & World Report associated it with the country's increasing youth unemployment.[23][7][24]

In Taiwan, where claw machine arcades are usually open all day and owners sublet their machines to different operators, claw machines became especially popular as inexpensive entertainment starting in , due to their costing NT$10 to use. The number of claw machine arcades in Taiwan increased from 920 in to 3,353 in and, as of , there are more than 10,000.[25] A survey of children aged seven to 18 reported 32.7 percent of them using claw machines one to three days a week and over four percent using them every day.[26] The Central Bank of the Republic of China increased their budget in to produce more NT$10 coins to accommodate the increasing popularity of claw machines in Taiwan. By , the average monthly revenue for operating a claw machine was around NT$5,000.[4]

The largest claw machine arcade in China, LJJ Station in Beijing, has more than 60 machines with stuffed toy versions of characters from WeChat animations.[27] Before , claw machines were popular in Thai shopping malls; a survey conducted by the advocacy group No Gambling Youth Club stated that 75 of the 92 shopping malls surveyed contained 1,300 claw machines collectively.[28][29]

Philippines

Cebu City now holds the record of having the world’s largest claw machine, Claw King. [30]

The world's largest claw machine, according to Guinness World Records, is 49.90 m³ (1,761 ft³) and was achieved by PlayFair an arcade located at TOPS landmark in Cebu City, Philippines. [31]

The massive claw machine was officially measured by a construction firm for Guinness World Records consideration, on 5 July . Built by Kuya Magik, The "Claw King" is 3.88 metres tall, 2.47 metres wide, and an huge 5.22 metres long! PlayFair added the machine to celebrate their arcade's mission of blending local "Perya" culture with modern entertainment and to put Cebu city on the global map.[32]

United States

In the United States, claw machines became ubiquitous in the s.[2] They are common at carnivals, grocery stores, shopping malls, arcades, amusement parks, and bowling alleys.[33][34][35]

The term "Clawcade" is used in the USA to refer to arcades that exclusively feature claw machines and prize-winning games.[36][37]

There were many instances of children getting stuck inside of claw machines in the United States throughout the s, including in Tennessee, New York, Kentucky, Nebraska, Pennsylvania,[35] North Carolina,[38] and Texas.[39]

Online and in popular culture

Online claw machines are claw machines controlled remotely online, with prizes that get shipped to users' homes upon being won.[40] Since the s, mobile apps, such as Clawee in Israel and Sega Catcher Online in Japan, and websites, such as Netch in Japan and the Santa Claw in the United States, have allowed users to remotely use claw machines stored in warehouses in their respective countries.[41][42][6][43]

The Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) video game Kirby's Adventure includes a minigame based on the UFO Catcher, while the PlayStation game Bomberman World has a UFO catcher-themed battle stage.[15][44] Sega's video game Yakuza and its sequels Yakuza 0 and Yakuza Kiwami also feature UFO Catcher machines.[45][46][47] The video game Link's Awakening includes a claw machine as a side activity.[48] In the film Toy Story, Buzz Lightyear and Sheriff Woody climb into a claw vending machine filled with claw-worshipping aliens.[49] In the SpongeBob SquarePants episode "Skill Crane" from its fourth season, Squidward becomes addicted to trying to win a prize from a claw machine.[50] Claw machines have also been featured in the music videos for Delta Heavy's song "Take Me Home", Corpsegrinder's song "Bottom Dweller", and the City Girls' song "Good Love".[51][52][53]

Legality

North America

The passing of the Johnson Act by Congress in , which prohibited the transfer of electronic gambling devices across state lines, led to Miami Diggers at carnivals being destroyed by operators or seized by government officials. Carnival owner Lee Moss organized other carnival owners together to protest against the classification of the diggers as gambling machines. Because of this, a compromise was soon reached that allowed carnival owners to keep the diggers but required them to be manually operated with no coin slot and prizes that were not money and worth one dollar or less, while the government would tax each machine US$10. Regulations loosened in due to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) abandoning the Johnson Act.[2] As of , state regulations generally require that claw machines contain less valuable prizes.[34] Most states exempt claw machines from their gambling laws.[54]

In California, claw machines are considered slot machines and their ownership and operation are prohibited by Penal Code Section 330b.

In New Jersey, claw machines are regulated by the Legalized Games of Chance Control Commission. In , New Jersey Senator Nicholas Scutari proposed legislation that would add specifications to prevent claw machines from being unwinnable.[54] In response to a spate of lawsuits against California claw game operators, attorney Bob Snyder advised claw machine owners to avoid using the word "skill" in the game description decal present on most machines.[55]

In other jurisdictions, such as Alberta, Canada, skill cranes are illegal unless the player is allowed to make repeated attempts (on a single credit) until he or she wins a prize.[56] Skill cranes in single-play mode (where the player has only one chance per credit to try for a prize) were found by the Ontario Court of Appeal to be essentially games of chance, and therefore prohibited except at fairs or exhibitions, where they are covered by an exemption.[57]

Asia

Claw machines were outlawed in Thailand after being classified as gambling devices by the Supreme Court of Thailand in , though, until , laws prohibiting their use were rarely enforced.[28] In , the Ministry of Interior in Thailand ordered a nationwide ban on claw machines after activists protested against their widespread availability.[29] However, the public prosecutor of Chiang Mai ruled in that claw machines were vending machines rather than gambling machines and were therefore legal.[58] South Korean law dictates that claw machines cannot carry prizes worth over ₩5,000 to prevent addiction. An investigation by South Korea's Game Rating and Administration Committee in found that the majority of claw machines they randomly inspected broke Korean law.[24] The Consumer Protection Committee of the Executive Yuan stated in that their investigation of claw machines in Taoyuan, New Taipei City, Kaohsiung, Taipei City, Tainan, and Taichung found that 70 percent of them contained illegal adult products such as vibrators and e-cigarettes.[59] In , the Ministry of Home Affairs in Singapore proposed capping the value of prizes in claw machines at S$100 in order to, according to them, "address the inducement effect of high-value prizes, without increasing the regulatory burden on operators".[60] In March , Brunei has banned claw machines as they have been deemed haram due to its gambling elements.[61]

Chances of winning

Since the s, advertising for claw machines has suggested that they are able to be won completely through strategy and skill. Claw machines can be set to give players a chance of winning during every paid turn if they use a "Play Till Win" setting.[3] Settings like claw strength—which is controlled by the amount of voltage sent to a claw—and "dropping skill"—the ability of a claw to drop a prize back into the machine after picking it up—are frequently modified by arcade owners to control the odds of a player winning and are often based on how much money the machine has earned.[34] Claw machine strength-control has been reported in the United States, South Africa, South Korea, and Singapore.[33][3][24][62]

On social media platforms such as TikTok and YouTube, videos of people using claw machines and offering modifications for how to get prizes from them were popular in the s and s.[63][3] A report by Vox's Phil Edwards describing how claw machines were often rigged went viral online and became controversial among claw machine enthusiasts.[64] A report by Jeff Rossen for the American TV program Today showing the same thing prompted the American Amusement Machine Association, which represents arcade game manufacturers across the United States, to make their members sign a "Fair Play Pledge" in that required their machines to be winnable through skill alone.[65] The book How to Beat the Claw Machine: Tips and Tricks to Help You Win Big, written by American arcade owner Brian McKanna, offers tips on how to win prizes at claw machines, which he described as "absolutely rigged".[66]

According to a report by News24, most claw machines in South Africa are rigged to only allow players to win if the machine has earned a certain amount of money.[67] A manual for the Intelligrab operating system, made by Belgian manufacturer Elaut, encourages claw machine owners to create the illusion that the player has a chance of winning if they keep trying, and owners can adjust machines' claw strength per turn.[3]

For more information, please visit Vending Machine.